Thursday, May 2, 2013

Germany’s Nuclear Energy Phaseout: The Timetable


By the end of 2022 Germany will have no nuclear power plants remaining. I have covered why this policy is folly elsewhere, so won’t cover it again here. Instead let us consider in a little detail how things will pan out in the next decade. To put the numbers in perspective I will estimate how much solar power will need to be added to replace the lost production due to each reactor being closed early (assuming a solar panel life span of 25 years and capacity factor of 10%). I’m using solar, not wind because the load factor for wind farms will be quite dependent on how much offshore wind is built, but if you want onshore wind figures just divide by 2.5.
Here’s the timetable of future reactor shutdowns:
2015: 1 reactor closes
Reactor: Grafenrheinfeld, (1.3 GW)
Average load factor: 85.8%
Original shut down date: 2028
Solar required to replace lost production: 6.8 GW
2017: 1 reactor closes
Reactor: Gundremmingen-B (1.3 GW)
Average load factor: 83.6%
Original shut down date: 2030
Solar required to replace lost production: 6.8 GW
2019: 1 reactor closes
Reactor: Phillipsburg-2 (1.4 GW)
Average load factor: 88.3%
Original shut down date: 2032
Solar required to replace lost production: 7.3 GW
2021: 3 reactors close
Reactor: Gundremmingen-C (1.4 GW)
Average load factor: 88.3%
Original shut down date: 2030
Solar required to replace lost production: 5 GW
Reactor: Brokdorf (1.4 GW)
Average load factor: 88.2%
Original shut down date: 2033
Solar required to replace lost production: 6.7 GW
Reactor: Grohnde (1.4 GW)
Average load factor: 90.4%
Original shut down date: 2031
Solar required to replace lost production: 5.6 GW
2022: 3 reactors close
Reactor: Isar-2 (1.4 GW)
Average load factor: 89.5%
Original shut down date: 2034
Solar required to replace lost production: 6.7 GW
Reactor: Emsland (1.3 GW)
Average load factor: 93.5%
Original shut down date: 2035
Solar required to replace lost production: 6.8 GW
Reactor: Neckarwestheim-2 (1.3 GW)
Average load factor: 92.3%
Original shut down date: 2036
Solar required to replace lost production: 7.3 GW

China struggles to tap its shale gas

In a remote corner of Sichuan with lush, terraced hillsides, oil exploration teams have been scaling cliffs to lay seismic charges and struggling to move heavy equipment along winding mountain roads. That is where China hopes to find vast stores of natural gas trapped in shale rock. The U.S. Energy Information Administration has estimated that China’s technically recoverable shale gas resources could be 50 percent bigger than those in the United States, where shale has transformed the energy sector. That has sparked hopes that unlocking those resources could help meet China’s relentlessly growing energy demand and ease its reliance on heavily polluting coal-fired power plants. But progress on China’s shale frontier has been slow. About 60 shale exploration wells have been drilled over the past two years, according to the consulting firm IHS CERA

Principles for the Pulse that is Peak Oil


A comment has just appeared below my post on The Wave/Pulse of Human History. “The Emergist” writes:
Nice article. Fun to see you weave together the separate stories. I didn’t know Holmgren was into Odum. How do you see the idea of pulsing as changing your approach to design, specifically bridging the gap between pulses? Or do you think there isn’t much we can do as individuals to bridge larger scale pulses?
I thought I’d answer here, as my Earth Day blog post. It seems appropriate to honor David Holmgren and Howard T. Odum on Earth Day, so much of this post will be extended excerpts from Holmgren’s 1994 article Energy and Permaculture.
Yes, Odum has been a huge influence on Holmgren (perhaps as much or more as his ‘in the flesh’ mentor Bill Mollison). As far back as the first Permaculture book (“Permaculture One”), with Holmgren as lead author, the first footnoted reference was to Howard T. Odum.
In the 1994 article, Holmgren writes:
The work of ecologist Howard Odum provided a theoretical framework and conceptual tool which was critical in the development of the permaculture concept. In the 1970′s there was a flurry of research in this field but it declined along with oil prices in the 1980′s. Odum was one of the leading ecologists who developed a systems approach to the study of human/environment interactions. He uses energy as a currency to compare and quantify the whole spectrum of natural and man-made elements and processes.
Odum’s ecosystem approach:
  • Analyses ecosystem elements and processes in terms of energy flows, storages. transformations. feedbacks, and sinks.
  • incorporates non-living and living elements of the natural environment.
  • and incorporates human systems and economies as an integral part of the natural world.
As I wrote in my post about the Pulse, “Howard Odum was of the opinion that all systems on all scales pulse. Storages gradually accumulate, consumers consume and develop, and eventually decline, and then dispersing materials that will be used in the next pulse.” And if “energy flows, storages, transformations, feedbacks, and sinks” are central to any system, man-made or otherwise, we can see that the peaking of world oil production is going to have a huge effect.

Feds triple estimates for recoverable natural gas in plains states


A new US Geological Survey study found that not only is the amount of the natural gas in the upper plains states of North and South Dakota and Montana three time larger than previously reported but that there was twice as much oil in there too.
Here’s the study. It summarizes its findings as:
Using a geology-based assessment methodology, the U.S. Geological Survey estimated mean undiscovered volumes of 7.4 billion barrels of oil, 6.7 trillion cubic feet of associated/dissolved natural gas, and 0.53 billion barrels of natural gas liquids in the Bakken and Three Forks Formations in the Williston Basin Province of Montana, North Dakota, and South Dakota.
The Interior Department explained the significance of this in a press release:
This assessment of both formations represents a significant increase over the estimated mean resource of 3.65 billion barrels of undiscovered oil in the Bakken Formation that was estimated in the 2008 assessment.
“These world-class formations contain even more energy resource potential than previously understood, which is important information as we continue to reduce our nation’s dependence on foreign sources of oil,” said Secretary of the Interior Sally Jewell. “We must develop our domestic energy resources armed with the best available science, and this unbiased, objective information will help private, nonprofit and government decision makers at all levels make informed decisions about the responsible development of these resources.”